[Perry] Judging a Book by its Cover
Guest Post by The Great and Powerful Perry.
—-
I judge books by their covers all the time.
Every time I’m looking for something new to read in a bookstore, I’ll be looking for either recognizable authors, books that have been recommended to me, or the cover art.
Recognizable authors come first. If a given author has already taken me on a wonderful journey, I’ll be more inclined to give them a blank check to try and repeat the experience. For them, their foot is already in the door to my mind and all they have to do is follow-up on the good impression they’ve already made.
By the same logic, if a friend recommends a book for me and I’ve enjoyed their selections before, I’m more likely to give them the benefit of the doubt.
For the rest of books out there, the cover art’s got to draw me. Not necessarily sell me, but draw me.
If I see a book with a fantastic cover and find out it’s a story about Peter the petulant possum pondering the philosophical philosophies of pineapples, I’m probably going to put that book back on the shelf and back away slowly. On the other hand, if the cover’s great and what little I see of the novel seems interesting enough, I’m pretty much sold.
This is the cover for Ashes of Candesce, by Karl Shroeder. I saw it in the bookstore and it immediately drew my attention. I was intrigued! Large open space, big sweeping staircases and trees! It struck me as a very elegant image and I wanted to know more about it. I wanted to meet the women languishing by the railing and find out what her story was. What little I found out about it only served to raise my level of interest to the point that I found the rest of the series.
All of that impulse decision-making (curse you impulse!) was made on the strength of the cover art.
If the cover had been a plain black field with just the title and the author, I likely would have passed right by it without a second thought and moved on with my life.
Book covers are important tools as they’re usually the first thing a reader sees. They serve to make that vital first impression on the behalf of the story within and it can be damned hard to draw in a reader with a cover that has no visual hook.
That’s not to say that cover art needs to be elegant and have a minimalist feel to it in order to be effective.
In this wonderful example, we have the cover to Split Infinity by Piers Anthony and indicative of the typical fantasy art at the time (the 80′s), it looks a little ridiculous.
But it’s an intriguing kind of ridiculous, isn’t it?
I mean, when I first met this book, I didn’t know that I wanted to read a story about a half naked man in a hat fencing a black unicorn with two white socks…but once I saw the picture, I was sold. I wanted to know more about this duel and the novel didn’t disappoint me.
Both of these covers follow two very different styles but they both accomplish the job of drawing the eye and getting a potential reader interested enough to at least pick up the book and take a look at it. After that, it’s up to the story to start carrying its own weight.
I kind of see the bookstore now the way I used to see toy stores when I was a little kid. It’s a complete sensory overload. It would have taken me years to play with every single toy in the store so my little brain was forced to compartmentalize, for its own sanity if nothing else.
In the same way, when I visit a bookstore, there’re far too many books for me to wrap my mind around so I don’t even try. I stick to known authors, recommended books, and anything past that needs to jump out from the shelf and grab my interest on its own.
All covers aren’t drawn the same, though.
I’ve found that what attracts me are covers that are fairly clean, with a clear and definable image.
I’m not really drawn to covers with little to nothing on them and in the same fashion, I can’t stand covers that look too busy either.
Looking through the Sci-Fi/Fantasy shelves, I see a lot of cover art featuring huge expansive battles with spell-casting wizards on the left, leprechauns stabbing pixies on the right with a huge aerial dogfight between Imperial Star Destroyers and dragons overhead.
That just strikes me as far too much.
Show me something simple that’ll hook me; give me something clean!
So what kind of covers will convince you to pick up a book?



22 Comments
Perry Wednesdays! So far, I like them very much.
I don’t really know what makes me like or dislike a cover. Commenting on your examples, I agree with all of them except the Piers Anthony. I remember seeing that one in a bookstore when I was young and I didn’t like it then. However, I still can’t tell you why. I guess I was not intrigued by the ridiculousness. Also – the unicorn is just standing there, he’s not really dueling at all!
I love the Karl Shroeder cover! I think it’s the implied vastness of the scene that draws me in. Have you read the book? Now I want to!
I’ve been struggling with my own cover, and even though I hired an artist, it’s hard to get it just right, especially at the bargain-basement price I’m willing to pay!
The Piers Anthony cover is one that I think it’s a good one, even though it drew me in and made me read the book. I picked it up because UNICORN — but the story itself is neither ridiculous nor cutesy unicorn. It’s actually a pretty good trilogy (it gets out of hand after the first three, but I still read them all).
Bargain basement pricing is definitely difficult to get really good stuff. My covers typically come from friends, and if they charged by the hour, I’d never be able to afford them.
Fine, you wouldn’t want to see a unicorn in white socks being threatened by a half-naked man with a sword and a hat? XD
(The unicorn’s a ‘she’ btw, but shhhh, you’ll hurt her feelings if she knows you guessed wrong >.>”)
That cover for Ashes of Candesce is actually the 6th and final book in the Virga series and I thought it well lived up to it’s grandiose cover art.
The story takes place in Virga which is like…kind of like a dyson-sphere? Imagine a huge, HUGE ball built in space around a mechanical star. The only gravity to be found within the sphere are generated by the people through centrifugal systems and the further you get from the star, the colder it gets until the very air freezes solid at the edges of the sphere, closest to space.
It’s utterly fascinating, and I’d recommend at least the first book if you’re interested at all in world-building on a marvelously fantastical scale.
Usually I would agree with the not-too-busy rule. I remember picking up a book called Havemercy in Barnes and Noble because – and only because – the cover is a mechanical dragon on a black background. Intriguing, and not too complicated.
But then again, when I saw the art for The Cry of the Icemark, I was drawn immediately even though it’s exactly that epic-battle type of cover.
Conclusion: I like clean, uncluttered covers, except when I like the cluttered ones??
That’s perfectly fine too haha.
There are a number of very busy covers that DID draw my eye and end up not letting me down, but for the most part, it’s the clean ones that REALLY pull me =)
*laugh* “I like clean, uncluttered covers, except when I like the cluttered ones??”
So true!
I think it’s that the cluttery covers are more difficult to get done RIGHT, you know? It’s like … chocolate bars are simple and I love them, but you’d damn well better not waste my time with a bad cheesecake, you know?
It takes little to convince me to pick up a book.
Cover art is important, but only for certain kinds of books. “The Man Who Loved Only Numbers” and “The Tao of Physics” are not books you pick up because of their cover art.
I remember when Middle Child was pretty young and he kept asking me to buy him “Eragon” based solely on the cover art. I finally agreed to this when he was in third grade. It is a well loved book in our home, but the initial draw was the cover. Repeatedly he was drawn to that book, and clearly well before he could actually read the whole thing.
When I was buying lots of children’s books, the art work was just as important as the content of the book. And the cover art is usually what made me pick up any of those books.
So is it clean, simple art, or complicated, cluttered art that draws me? It just has to be interesting art. Interesting is pretty expansive and hard to categorize.
I totally agree on the Eragon covers — they just … draw you in. Something about the jewel-toned colors and the detail in the scales.
Also, I think “The Tao of Physics” and its ilk deserve awesome covers. More people need to read that kind of stuff. <3
Lol….
Dear sweet lord of fluffy muffins and pancakes.
Who on EARTH would something like this appearl to, I wonder…
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-hW8gw8YVVgc/UDvBrkEf9MI/AAAAAAAAI8M/NUR0j_p_jfY/s1600/The%2BSkybound%2BSea.jpg
*shudders* I fear…gasp….and if I say this out loud does it come true…that Youngest Child may actually pick up that book.
Youngest Child seems drawn to …oh, if I say it out loud is it real…romance novels. *gasp*
Seriously! What is wrong with that child?
Nicholas Sparks seems to be her cup of tea. I truly cannot comment, as I have no idea what his books are like, except that I would have to be locked in a dungeon for years before I would consider reading one.
Going to the library with her is like some surreal trip to Oz. She brings over books that she has chosen and she is giddy with pride and excitement. I look at them with confusion. THAT book cover is about what I would expect in one of those interactions.
Hee hee.
That doesn’t look like a romance novel, though!
It looks like…..well, to be honest with you, I’ve absolutely no idea what it looks like.
But I’m wondering if THAT scene is in the book itself…like, a guy with “thimply fabulouth long lockth” and a constipated girl in tights standing directly under a waterfall to pose for a picture? OO
Yikes on Sparks. Yikes to a billion.
http://www.newsinfilm.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/sparks_cracked.jpg
That’s Nicholas Sparks novels, in like … 30 seconds. (it’s an info-graphic, not an article).
He’s famous for out-of-left-field tragedy that breaks a couple up just as they’ve found each other, only to kill off at least one of them by the end.
Not my cup of romance tea. Not at all.
And I do like romances. =]
I’m also glad I started reading romances early. I saw a lot of relationships, what worked, what didn’t work, where conflicts came from … and it made me expect better treatment from my future husband than I might otherwise have expected.
Some of them may be goofy or dumb … but I wear my Romance Novel Reader ribbon with pride. <3
She seems drawn to the romance novels, something with which our household is qutie unfamiliar. I don’t even know how to recommend such books. And, let’s be honest here, if you chose a romance novel by cover art…WHAT? It is the same picture!!! Maybe a different setting, so some balls gowns, some blue jeans. What??
All I can recommend is a “romance ‘ novel Steve Martin wrote. I am not even sure of the title, but it is a romance. In a quirky, stalker kinda way. And I KNOW for sure that the cover art is NOT a pciture of a couple in love’s embrace.
You have to read a lot of bad romance novels before you figure out which kinds work for you and which don’t. =]
*smirks* There are good romance novels?
And if so, can the cover art lend itself to identifiying the good from the bad? I cannot be the only one who perceives all romance cover art as the same picture.
The cover art will often tell you the age of the book (and sometimes, the kinds of stories you will or will not find in there) but you have to read a lot of them to get the kind of discerning eye that would allow you to disregard a book based on the cover.
And yes, there are excellent romance novels. =]
If I had to make one random stab in the dark…
Man with amazing, unattainable hair.
He’s dressed in a button up shirt that’s inexplicably not buttoned up (gasp).
Standing in front of him with her back to him is a woman with amazing, unattainable hair.
She’s wearing a dress with a plunging neckline and she has a figure that Barbie can only dream of (gasp).
One of her arms are reaching back behind her head to cup the back of the man’s neck.
The man’s hands are holding her low down on her stomach, implying a strong, masculine strength and traces of tenderness (swoon).
Did I do it right?
Can I design romance covers now? XD
I’m really not very good at recognizing a pleasing cover. If you wouldn’t mind helping me out, my current sample can be found here:
https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/kLe2Kku0Ls_tbtO-kbH5X7ac83fNB9V8oTFDDly-FNk?feat=directlink
Oh yea – don’t read the back cover text too closely, it’s merely filler at this point!
(If this is too presumptuous, please delete the comment!)
See, something like that?
I think it’s perfectly fine for what it is.
While it doesn’t really strike me as “elegant” like the Candesce example, it’s a very…how to put this…like, ‘no frills’ deal?
Like it knows exactly what image it’s trying to convey and doesn’t beat about the bush, you know?
“My story’s about a cyborg with an integrated weapons system in a futuristic setting.”
The only other comment I’d really have would be that I don’t think the shadows on the lettering needs to be there (the green glow seems fancy enough to me ^^) but that’s 110% a personal stylistic choice =)
Thanks Perry – that’s very helpful because I have no artistic eye at all!
I agree with the lettering too, I’ve already had the artist tone it down some, but I think getting rid of the shadows altogether is a good idea.
I agree with Perry — I’d say the art itself is perfect for what it’s conveying. The wording is difficult to read, though. I’d recommend putting a blank box behind the back-jacket text, so it doesn’t need to be read on top of all that detail. You could make it a metal, future-y box … but it should allow the back text to be easily scanned without squinting past background noise.
Looks great, though! Like Perry said, no hiding the future/cyborg action-y stuff. (Hopefully all that’s in your novel. /laugh)
Well, I like it because it reminds me of the classic sci-fi novels from the 70s. Asimov, Bradbury and… dare I say Hubbard? I might not have ever noticed shadowing, lettering or such. Would that make me pick up the book?? Yes!
Would my kids///
One would, the other might and the third would disregard it for lack of romance.